Lesson comparing a poem and prose summary of a poem. Divide the class into small groups and give each group a sheet of paper and one index card that you prepared in advance see preparation, step 1. Formative assessments are d istributed and noted throughout each lesson e. Four instructionallevel examples of compare contrast texts. This lesson emphasizes the usefulness of developing strong thesis statements and effective outlines as part of the writing process. Vocabulary mini lesson comparison contrast context clues. The problem is that waiting until the end implies that the focus of compare contrast is more about getting the right answer instead of discovering and learning more about the content. Comparing and contrasting is a fundamental skill both for writing and reading comprehension. Three informative writing units, each with full lesson plans 3 weeks in all.
Field trip to a pumpkin farm students will go to a pumpkin farm to observe pumpkins, then compare and contrast pumpkins on a venn diagram. Nov 15, 2018 picture this a math lesson that focuses on compare contrast using variations of shutter speed in photography teaching the compare contrast essay steps a teacher has used to teach the compare contrast essay to regular classes of high school sophomores whose reading levels range from fourth to twelfth grade. Compare and contrast the most important points and key details presented in two texts on the same topic. Compare and contrast is one of my favorite literacy skills to teach early in the year because it is approachable for students and can be used in so many different ways. View the online guide using an lcd projector or gather your students around the classroom computer. Reveal your thinking to students as you fill in the chart during and after reading. Because of winndixie unit plan teaching portfolio of. Give students a clear purpose for comparingcontrasting so that identifying similarities and differences is an ongoing search throughout your lesson. Then show how to use the information to draw a relevant conclusion. Youll find a lesson on how authors reveal character traits, two character trait lists, a variety of graphic organizers, several cooperative learning activities, and a list of suggested character trait books. In addition, making connections by teaching compare and contrast to elementary students is a relatively easy task, making it great for the beginning of the school year. Exploring compare and contrast structure in expository texts.
Its part of a huge library of lessons that span grades k12 and every. Decide which elements you need to compare and contrast to answer the question. Mostly i stopped at parts that felt importantlike reiterating the number of immigrants who came through each station yearly. Hi rob, youre probably experiencing technical difficulties with th. Lesson comparing a poem and prose summary of a poem reading.
Compare and contrast for kids learn how to compare and. Informational texts read the following paragraphs, and then answer the questions that follow. Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story e. Understand events, trends, individuals and movements shaping the. Compare contrast mini unit freebie from diary of a not so wimpy teacher. Compare and contrast teachercreated lesson plan common.
Reading minilesson compare and contrastthis minilesson is designed to assist students in creating comparison contrast statements. Apr 14, 2014 this is a pdf file on compare and contrast for gr 3 4 students. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on youtube. Duplicating any part of this book is prohibited by law. The following is a list of lessons that are included in the connect, compare, and contrast genres unit. This lesson builds on lessons 68, with students comparing and contrasting the two texts they read in those lessons. Compare and contrast signal words teach students that there are certain words that usually indicate a need to compare or contrast information.
Tell students that today they are going to compare and contrast texts that are written about the same topic. Plant pumpkins, see what happens students will put into practice their knowledge of pumpkin. This is designed to help the teacher differentiate this lesson and to allow all students to feel successful explanation of craftivity. In addition, the wording in questions addressing these skills does not vary a great deal. This mini pack includes a variety of strategies and printables for teaching students how to analyze character traits. This lesson uses bags paper or cloth filled with nonfiction books containing different text structures to help the. Ask students to volunteer definitions for the terms compare note the similarity between and contrast note the difference between.
Plant pumpkins, see what happens students will put into practice their knowledge of pumpkin growth, planting, caring for, and observing their own pumpkin. A complete guide to teach students how to compare and contrast when reading in english. Each lesson has been assigned a number that correlates to a number found in the upper right corner of each lesson card, which signifies a suggested sequence or progression of the lessons. I can crah a wrien response comparing a poem to a prose summary of a poem. Comparing fictional texts mini lesson book units teacher. Goal tree decorate bottles and put a goal inside inspired by gloria dumps mistake tree reading intervention no hw vocabulary read ch. This lesson emphasizes the usefulness of developing strong thesis statements and effective outlines as. I can compare and contrast important points and key details from two texts on the same topic.
In this video we will learn how to compare and contrast or find similarities or differences between almost any object. The first nine slides of the comparison and contrast guide encompassing the overview, definition, and example tabs are most appropriate for this discussion. You can use the california treasures writing and grammar intervention guides section on linguistic differences to find the lessons that can be used to help sels understand how to compare and contrast the way a particular grammar rule is used in home language and school language 7. A compare and contrast lesson lesson plan from educatio. Access thousands of highquality, free k12 articles, and create online assignments with them for your students. All the students are from an inner city community, holyoke, ma. Lesson 4 comparing ecosystems home schoolmessenger. Aug 03, 2017 compare and contrast stories in the same genre e. After i felt like we had a handle on the vocabulary, i read the coming to america article out loud to my students, stopping to think aloud. Readwritethinks comparison and contrast guide can be used to help explain these terms. Students build their understanding of the terms compare and contrast by. Practice making inferences about stories with the help of this writing organizer. The unit compare and contrast bats and birds uses the book stellaluna, which keeps the kid.
Venn diagram for students venn diagram with sample vocabulary for comparing and contrasting for student reference differentiated writing tools. How to teach students to compare and contrast in your digital. Making connections read the civil war poem and compare to what we learn in the novel reading intervention no hw quiz mini lesson. Write 6 hort responses compare and contrast how you learn about the characters in the drama and the story. How to incorporate other helping students make texttoself connections by comparing and contrasting is an important foundational skill. I can compare a poem to the visual interpretahon of the poem. Unit objectives are measured using the following graphic organizers. When they see these words, they should know what they are expected to do. In order to understand nonfiction as a genre, it is useful to compare and contrast various text nonfiction text structures e. Summative assessment would simply involve measuring your plants. Explain that the same process can be done with an expository text that compares and contrasts two things. Youll find a lesson on how authors reveal character traits, two character trait lists, a variety of graphic organizers, several cooperative learning activities, and a.
Day 1 opinion essay preassessment common core ccss. Each has higher level thinking with compare and contrast activities involving animals, graphic organizers, and final products. Compare and contrast texts on the same topic lesson plan. Turn and talk, partner work, 321 summarizer, ticket out the door, etc. Comparing and contrasting within and between texts unit. Use the chart on page 335 to organize your thoughts. Compare and contrast starter activity, p5 structured compare and contrast paragraph, p15 suggested amount of time. Comparison and contrast is one of the 30 microlessons mini lessons available in the series, language arts presenter.
Improve your students reading comprehension with readworks. Fables lesson or moral fairy tales tall tales myths o science fiction o informational genreencyclopedia, textbooks, magazines descriptive informational text patterns. For example, if the class discussed pets in the first lesson, select a text that describes the qualities and care of an unusual pet, such. Mufaros beautiful daughters lesson plan scholastic. Lesson comparing a poem and visual display of the poem reading mini. Students will compare and contrast characters and themes of poetry and texts to document similarities and differences. Comparative thinking is great for building connections between background knowledge and new concepts. Sixth grade lesson compare and contrast nonfiction. Compare and contrast o compare and contrast narrative to informational. A great starting point to writing a compare and contrast essay. Students will compare and contrast two or more versions of stories. This lesson is from teaching students to read nonfiction, by alice boynton and wiley blevins.
Compare and contrast first grade reading lesson 1, standards. Here is the word search activity for comparison and contrast. These compare and contrast worksheets help students practice identifying how characters, story details or ideas are alike or different. The demographics in the chart below are from 20152016. While it is certainly interesting to compare and analyze. Help students understand the importance of understanding text structure by explaining that a reader who is aware of the patterns that are being used can anticipate the. This is a pdf file on compare and contrast for gr 3 4 students. I found this to be a very good lesson plan on the compare and contrast text structure. Just connect your computer to a digital projector or smart board, select a student to operate the mouse and let peter, the avatar, teach your kids a lesson on comparison and contrast. Compare and contrast activities teaching made practical. Distribute the text structures chart printable and explain what text structures are and what clues students can use to identify text structures. Grammar lessons revision mini lessons proofreading mini lessons contrasve analysis lessons lessons that help students compare and contrast the use of a selected language rule use of third person singular verb for example in standard english and aal aave.
Check out this lesson from a classroom teacher who uses common sense education. Assessment as a garden shirley clark 2001 used a beautiful analogy of the school as a garden and the students as the plants. Preparation before the lesson, select two texts on topics similar to the topics used in the first lesson. Compare and contrast worksheets lesson plan pdfs kidskonnect. Because many ells enter school without having had the benefit of meeting the. Hinton compose a variety of writing assignments relating to themes, characters, identity, and selfidentity create a portfolio box that portrays their personal identity and their journal entries, assignments, and final project unit assessment. I created the compare and contrast mini unit to provide students. Students will learn several strategies for organizing short, persuasive essays, preferably after they have started prewriting. Compare and contrast characteristics of a functional systolic murmur and a pathologic murmur. Include at least two details from each passage to your. Anchor chart 2 passages on fast animals task cards.
Correctly identify common systolic murmurs on an audio recording. Short stories your students will read two short stories, then compare and contrast the characters, problems, solutions, and themes with the help of a graphic organizer. Brown pelicans live mainly near saltwater ecosytems, such as bays and oceans. The settlers left a small hole in the front for the door. Review the strategy by showing how to compare and contrast previous knowledge, personal opinions, and assumptions with what you just read. The ability to compare and contrast is critical for comprehending literary and informational textsand for writing them. Work the prompts for compare and contrast on the teaching card into the chart. Topics for focused mini lessons expectations, routines, and rules in reading workshop intro to how to use reading logs, folders, etc.
Students will read a variety of poetry included in this unit to determine how conflict shapes our lives and how different texts can shape our lives. Compare and contrast guide student interactive from the read write think site. This mini unit was created for a first grade class with approximately 22 students. Exploring compare and contrast structure in expository. The words found in the activity above become the word bank for this crossword puzzle. Students will use appropriate discourse for the academic language when. How to teach students to compare and contrast in your. Compare and contrast a fictional portrayal of a time, place, or character and a historical account of the same period as a means of understanding how authors of fiction use or. After analyzing the grade level expectations, district. Review the venn diagram graphic organizer by modeling how to use it compare contrast the sun and the moon. Seventh grade ela units of study new bedford high school. Teaching the compare and contrast essay through modeling. How are paleontologists different from archaeologists.
245 1612 143 1076 83 483 1652 880 1080 656 240 762 27 1197 1130 457 1264 1519 617 500 126 108 799 508 525 3